• O. Pavlenko Kharkiv National Automobile and Highway University
  • D. Velykodnyi Central Ukrainian National Technical University
Keywords: rational scheme, delivery, freight forwarding company, profit


The paper analyzes this day state of development and current trends in the forming of a rational scheme for servicing cargo delivery orders within the framework both individual enterprises and transport on the whole. It’s allowed to form the main purposes of the study this article. The scientific works about the cargo delivery improvement by the freight forwarding enterprise focus on the development of effective interaction between the process participants, but they don't consider possible changes in the execution of technological operations under the impact of relevant factors. It has been determined there is a need to choose a methodical approach to form a rational order servicing scheme to further reduce the cost of cargo delivery and accordingly to increase the profits of freight forwarding enterprise. Seven alternative schemes of servicing the order for the cargo delivery by the freight forwarding company have been proposed. They take into account the possible combinations of the relevant operations list execution that accompany the transport process organization and realization. The process of choosing a rational scheme for the cargo delivery is guided by the maximum profit and considers the established parameters, such as: the customer service scheme, the transportation distance, the volume of cargo. In order to obtain the most reliable data on the parameters of the transport process, the required number of observations has been determined; it amounted to 127 observations of the volume of shipment, and 142 ones of the delivery distances. The developed plan of full-factorial experiment allows to adequately assessing the effect of initial parameters (a shipment volume and a delivery distance) on the efficiency criterion (an enterprise's profit). The model's reproducibility check was performed with use Cochran's criterion, that was amounted 0.9779; it means the experiment can will be reproduce. According to certain assumptions, values of initial data and duration of operations that were performed by the enterprise, it has been calculated the values of the elements of the estimation indicator – income and expenses for each scheme of service, as well as the efficiency criterion – the profit. On the basis of the regression analysis of the experiment's results, a regression model in linear form with a non-zero coefficient has been determined, in which each coefficient indicates the respective factor influence quantity on the resultant indicator – the profit. It is found this model is the most adequate because the value of the "R-square" is the largest and equal to 1. The results of the profit determination showed that the highest level of the indicator is achieved when servicing the order for cargo delivery of 21.45 tons for a distance of 1817 km according to the scheme service № 5; it is the least costly in terms of number of services, time of work execution, when the vehicles and handling machinery are used effectively enough. In this case the company makes a profit of 28951.86 UAH, which is many 26292.69 UAH than servicing the order the existing in the enterprise scheme № 2.

Author Biographies

O. Pavlenko, Kharkiv National Automobile and Highway University

Ph.D., Associate Professor

D. Velykodnyi, Central Ukrainian National Technical University

Ph.D., Associate Professor


Nagorny, E., Lomotko, D., Shramenko, N., Naumov, V., Pavlenko, A. (2013) Forwarding activities. Kharkiv: KhNADU, 352.

Cargo turnover of transport enterprises (n.d.). Retrieved from:

Velykodnyi, D., Pavlenko, O. (2017). The choice of rational technology of delivery of grain cargoes in the containers in the international traffic. International journal for traffic and transport engineering, 7(2), 164-175.

Orda, O.O., Shramenko, N.Y. (2015). Forming of the for-warding service alternative variants in intermodal transporta-tion. Automobile transport, 37, 70-77.

Naumov, V., Kholeva, O. (2017). Studying Demand for Freight Forwarding Services in Ukraine on the Base of Logis-tics Portals. Data Procedia Engineering, 187, 317-323.

Okyere, S., Yang, J.Q., Aning, K.S., Zhan, B. (2019). Review of Sustainable Multimodal Freight Transportation System in African Developing Countries: Evidence from Ghana. International Journal of Engineering Research in Afri-ca, 41, 155-174.

Aulin, V., Lyashuk, O., Pavlenko, O., Velykodnyi, D., Hrynkiv, A., Lysenko, S., Holub, D., Vovk, Y., Dzyura, V., Sokol, M. (2019). Realization of the logistic approach in the international cargo delivery system. Communications - Scien-tific Letters of the University of Zilina, 21(2), 3-12.

Rossolov, A., Kopytkov, D., Kush, Y., Zadorozhna V. (2017). Research of effectiveness of unimodal and multimodal transportation involving land modes of transport. Eastern-European Journal of Enterprise Technologies, 5(89), 60-69.

Naumov, V. (2018). Modeling Demand for Freight For-warding Services on the Grounds of Logistics Portals Data. Transportation Research Procedia, 30, 324-331.

Wang, X., Kopfer, H., Gendreau, M. (2014). Operational transportation planning of freight forwarding companies in horizontal coalitions. European Journal of Operational Re-search, 237(3), 1133-1141.

Krajewska, M.A., Kopfer, H. (2019). Transportation planning in freight forwarding companies: Tabu search algo-rithm for the integrated operational transportation planning problem. European Journal of Operational Research, 197 (2), 741-751.

Naumov, V., Omelchenko, T. (2017). Model of the Deliv-ery Routes Forming Process as a Service Provided by For-warding Companies. Procedia Engineering, 187, 167-172.

Rosanoa, M., Demartinia, C.G., Lambertia, F., Perboliab, G. (2018) A mobile platform for collaborative urban freight transportation. Transportation Research Procedia, 30, 14-22.

Nefyodov, V., Pavlenko, O., Kalinichenko, O. (2018) The technique to form the resource-saving technology of cargo delivery by the transport and logistics center. Municipal economy of cities, 142, 96-102.

Bian, G.R., Li, H.S., Dai, G.L. (2012). Research on the Optimization of Transportation Routing Problem of Warehouse Material Based on Self-Adaptive Ant Colony Algorithm. Applied Mechanics and Materials, 236-237, 1122-1127.

Kopytkov, D., Pavlenko O. (2019). An approach to deter-mine the rational scheme of delivery for the international consolidated shipments. Municipal economy of cities. 147(1), 35-41.

Naumov, V., Shulika, O., Velikodnyi, D. (2015). Results of experimental studies on choice of automobile intercity transport delivery schemes for packaged cargo. MOTROL. Commission of Motorization and Energetics, 17(7), 87-91.

Hanbazazah, A.S., Abril, L., Erkoc, M., Shaikh, N. (2019). Freight consolidation with divisible shipments, delivery time windows, and piecewise transportation costs. European Jour-nal of Operational Research. 276(1), 187-201.

Saeed, N. (2013). Cooperation among freight forwarders: Mode choice and intermodal freight transport. Research in Transportation Economics, 42(1), 77-86.

Chen, G., Cheung, W., Chu, S.C., Xu, L. (2017). Trans-shipment hub selection from a shipper's and freight forwarder's perspective. Expert Systems with Applications, 83, 396-404.

Sosik, K., Turzeniecka, M., Iwan, S. (2019). Difficulties affecting distribution process in a city - a forwarder perspective. Transportation Research Procedia, 39, 480-487.

Harry K. H., Chow K. L., Choy W. B. A strategic knowledge-based planning system for freight forwarding industry. Expert Systems with Applications. 2007. Vol. 33, Is. 4. P. 936-954.

Shramenko, N., Pavlenko, O., Muzylyov, D. (2019). Information and Communication Technology: Case of Using Petri Nets for Grain Delivery Simulation at Logistics System, CEUR Workshop Proceedings, 2353, 935-949.

Kopytkov, D., Pavlenko, O., Kalinichenko, O. (2018). A technique to determine the optimum package of logistic services provided by the transport and logistics centre. Modern Management: Logistics and Education. Monograph. 150-157.

Konovalenko, I., Ludwig, A. (2019). Event processing in supply chain management – The status quo and research out-look. Computers in Industry, 105, 229-249.

Naumov, V. (2012). Definition of the optimal strategies of transportation market participators. Transport Problems: an International Scientific Journal, 7(1), 43-52.

Aulin, V., Pavlenko, O., Velikodnyy, D., Kalinichenko, O., Zielinska, A., Hrinkiv, A., Diychenko, V., Dzyura, V. (2019). Methodological approach to estimating the efficiency of the stock complex facing of transport and logistic centers in Ukraine. Proceedings Paper 1st International Scientific Con-ference on Current Problems of Transport (ICCPT), 120-132

How to Cite
PavlenkoO., & VelykodnyiD. (2020). FORMING OF A RATIONAL SCHEME OF SERVICING ORDERS FOR CARGO DELIVERY BY THE FREIGHT FORWARDING COMPANY. Municipal Economy of Cities, 1(154), 223-230. Retrieved from